Wednesday, February 14, 2007

Revision is OF THE DEVIL



There. Now I feel better.

After reading about--for what must have been around a thousand times--the orgasm, i.e. miracle, that is revision I feeling completely turned off toward the concept. In the past I've often found it difficult to polish some of my poems into any thing except v. shiny garbage, so forgive me (or not) if I don't feel completely blown away by the concept.

That being said, I can see the potential in this concept and it is an improvement. Any time you put back a "final draft" and give it a second look, it's not difficult to find at least some ways to improve on it. I remember this happening many a time during my undergrad when I'd pull an all-nighter, finish up, and think of all the improvements I could make if I had time to "sleep on it" and revise.

In particular, I liked The Writer's Toolbox because it offered practical ways to help my students, which IS something worth getting excited about.

Grammar Girl's Quick and Dirty Tips for Better Writing (Kids like podcasts, and she's funny.) Being the huge nerd that I am I have a live bookmark to it. She's got topics that are complex enough for us and ones simple enough to help students improve their writing.

Wednesday, January 31, 2007

hide sharp objects, am reading Williams again.

k. This is not my entire post, and really is not at the heart of the substance of my post, but I just have to say something!

As an educator the idea that a student has the "right" to write poorly or go off topic just seems wrong. It haven't read these chapters yet, but it sort of strikes me as similar to when people say they have a "right to their own opinion" when what they are arguing is not a matter of opinion, but actually one of fact and can be proven untrue. Their claim to such a "right" is based on fallacious logic.

While good/bad writing and on/off topic IS a matter of opinion, it becomes less so once students step into the classroom. How else can a teacher evaluate his students? I just get this bizarre image of someone being handcuffed and brought into the classroom and read their rights. Then, when they fail the course they argue, "I have the right to write badly!" I'm hoping as I sit down to read this book I come to a better understanding of Spandel's ultimate goal.

Having looked over the preface and taken a sneak peek of the other chapters, it seems she is hovering between rights and needs. I agree students should feel free to make mistakes. I just really do not like the trend/idea, especially with creative writing, that there is no real standard of quality. (What does it mean to you?, etc.) The question is, how DO we evaluate?

Also, with with Spandel I'm running up against that problem, once again, that these ideas don't seem quite practical. I think it might be sort of cool to imagine the inside of a pencil. I've also been in lots of classes where students were able to choose their topics and it didn't seem to make much of a difference either way. I'd drop dead if I gave an assignment that made my students run through the grass singing "Tra-la-la" and begging for pen and paper. Maybe I'll figure it out and one day they'll make a movie about me and Michelle Pfeiffer will play me. Oh, wait. They already did that.

I do like the idea of letting students try to choose something that holds personal value for them. I'm not saying I'm against that. But I also think that we can give them topics/tools they may not think of. This might help them discover something. Maybe it's just that I'm getting more and more frustrated as we get to the end of the program and we keep talking about all these solutions that seem to contradict each other.

On the other side of the spectrum we have Williams. I think it's just his writing style. The tone or something. He seems really judgmental and negative. Damn. I absolutely loved hearing about the multi-genre concept after he trashed the idea of combining literature and expository writing, which I thought was completely bogus when I read it last week. And that's the thing about Williams, it wasn't presented as his theory, it was put forth as the only option. That's something I was told never to do when making an argument because it is a major turn off to your audience.

I will definitely put something together that is multi-genre because I feel like it's a low-pressure situation for students to try out different forms of creative writing. Their entire grade isn't riding on whether they can write an awesome poem, etc. and I think that will help them. It will also give them an automatic topic. However, I think I will make it mandatory that my students include some formal expository writing along with the project.

Monday, January 22, 2007

Wk 2: What should be obvious. And grammar!

Initially I was turned off by what Williams was saying. I tend to get defensive b/c after all, here we are! We did some how manage to learn something from the miserable classroom and teaching methods we're all criticizing. But, after I get over that, I can move on to see that what I'm reading makes sense. A lot of times when I read these sort of "How to Teach" things, I sort of think, well, OF COURSE. I forget that, what comes naturally to some of us (the process or writing, reading) isn't that way for everyone else. So, it's great to see that they are putting the "process approach" or whatever they want to call it, down on paper, into concrete stages.

I really liked the part about "divorcing" editing from the rest of the writing process, and not just because people worry about errors and may stifle their creativity. It's important to realize that such errors are inevitable. (That's why we have erasers.) And this way students can sit down in their last stages and THINK about why their grammar/usage is incorrect. Why doesn't this sentence make sense? subj/verb agreement, etc. Then they understand what that is. If they hurry over that while writing their papers it won't mean anything to them and they will probably be more likely to make that mistake again. This is an excellent example of grammar in context, which seems much more affective than writing vocab words and sentences--which I had to do even in high school. (I had a BISCUIT for breakfast. X 6)

At first I thought, workshops for essay writing, what? Pairs definitely makes more sense to me. That's pretty much what I did during my undergrad anyway, I'd show my paper to a trusted friend, who I knew would give me an honest opinion. Again, we're modeling these ideas off what good writers already do, so it's hard to go wrong. It seems that Carney has adapted the process well for the classroom. These workshops give you the benefit of input from your classmates, but the responsibility lies with the individual writer. I think that's v. important.

Okay, so I'm not a genius or anything because I had no idea what to list as a link, but I was surfing around for associated sites and found this site, TeenLit, and the more I looked at it, the more the writing tools seemed really cool. It would be a great places for your students to go in class when they needed some help and it looks like they have a publication as well. Also, it had a list of cites where kids can buy papers--so you can catch them cheating!